The Catacombs Reference Library
The Episode Critics
Compiled by Martin Willey

Click on episode title for comments by Richard Houldsworth, Chris Bentley, John Kenneth Muir, James O'Neill, Anthony McKay and others.

Number Episode Dreamwatch (out of 10) Chris Bentley/ SFX Sci-Fi On Tape (out of 8) Bob Wood (out of 10)
(2002)
Bob Wood (out of 10)
(2010)
Alasdair Stuart (out of 5)
1 Breakaway 7 A+ 6 8.5 8 4
2 Matter Of Life And Death B- 5 8 7 4
3 Black Sun 8 A 5 9.5 9 3
4 Ring Around The Moon 3 C- 4 7 6 2
5 Earthbound 9 A 6 9 8 3
6 Another Time, Another Place 5 A+ 6 10 9.5 3
7 Missing Link 7 C+ 6 8.5 8 2
8 Guardian of Piri 3 A 4 9.5 9 3
9 Force Of Life 9 A- 5 9.5 9 3
10 Alpha Child 7 B- 5 6 5 4
11 The Last Sunset 7 A+ 4 9 7.5 4
12 Voyager's Return 9 B+ 4 8.5 7.5 4
13 Collision Course 4 B+ 5 10 9 3
14 Death's Other Dominion 10 A+ 5 10 8.5 3
15 The Full Circle 5 C 3 8 6.5 2
16 End Of Eternity 5 A 4 9 8 4
17 War Games 8 A- 4 10 9.5 5
18 The Last Enemy C 4 7 5 3
19 The Troubled Spirit A+ 5 10 9 2
20 Space Brain B- 4 7 6.5 2
21 The Infernal Machine A+ 5 9.5 9 3
22 Mission Of The Darians A+ 5 10 9 3
23 Dragon's Domain A+ 7 10 9 4
24 The Testament Of Arkadia A+ 4 10 9 4
25 The Metamorph 8 A 6 9 8.5
26 The Exiles 3 B+ 5 9 8
27 One Moment Of Humanity 8 B 5 10 9
28 All That Glisters 6 D- 1 6.5 5.5
29 Journey To Where 7 A- 6 10 9
30 The Taybor 6 D- 4 6 5
31 The Rules Of Luton 7 D+ 5 5 4.5
32 The Mark Of Archanon 9 B+ 4 4 3.5
33 Brian The Brain 6 B+ 5.5 4
34 New Adam, New Eve 5 B 9 8
35 The Catacombs Of The Moon 7 B+ 8.5 8
36 The A B Chrysalis 5 A- 9 8.5
37 Seed Of Destruction 4 B+ 9 8
38 The Beta Cloud 2 C- 6 4
39 A Matter Of Balance D- 6.5 6
40 Space Warp 4 D 6.5 5.5
41 The Bringers Of Wonder 6 A 4 7 7.5
43 The Lambda Factor 5 A- 9 8
44 The Seance Spectre B- 9 8.5
45 Dorzak A- 8.5 7
46 Devil's Planet B+ 8 7
47 The Immunity Syndrome 7 B 9.5 9
48 The Dorcons 5 B+ 9 8