Matter of Life and Death was shot using a revised script dated 8th January 1974, with previous revisions dated 17 December and 27 December 1973. The shooting schedule was published on the 10th January, with filming starting on Monday 14th January. It was due to finish on Monday 28th January after 11 filming days; in fact, it overran 2 days, finishing on Wednesday 20th after 13 days.
In Byrne's version of the script, the mystery has been dialled up, while the illusions, revealing the character's backgrounds and emotions, have been removed. Only the illusion of the verdant planet remains (in the Wallace script, it is not seen; we see only the barren rocky reality). In the end, there is an unseen alien force trying to keep the Alphans from the planet, but Lee Russell is really Helena's husband ("What I became, what I now am, ended up here on this planet.").
In the Wallace script, Telford Russell wakes up early, and there is some nice dialogue between him and Helena: "The speed of your recovery....the fact that you were able to get out of bed at all." "Iron Man McGinty... isn't that what you used to call me?" "Funny, I was just thinking of that, myself.". There's also good dialogue with Koenig: "Why did I have to be Helena's husband? That's the only fact that's really bothering you, Commander, and you know it!" In the Byrne script, Lee Russell is unconscious for much of the episode and then dies. Helena has very little interaction with him, and Koenig has only one significant interrogation scene with Lee.
There is one significant scene that was filmed but cut. After Lee dies in the interrogation, Koenig goes to talk to Helena in her quarters ("I've already said it all to myself, John. I don't blame anyone for what happened to Lee."). At the end of the scene, Koenig and Helena are called to Medical. The scene was filmed (on Wednesday 16th January), and photos of Stuart Damon sitting up in bed exist.
43
Revised 27/12/73.
43 CONTD. 2
KOENIG
What's wrong, Mathias?
MATHIAS
(on T.V screen)
Parks and Bannion have regained
consciousness.
CUT TO:
44 DELETED
45 DELETED
46 DELETED
47 INT. CARE UNIT. 47
ON THE VSI MONITORS. They are pulsing in a
very
healthy way.
ANGLE WIDENS
Bannion and Parks are being debriefed by
Koenig.
Helena is in the Care Unit beside him.
PARKS
The planet is fine, Sir. We
were down there, we walked
about.
BANNION
It's a great place to be...
KOENIG
Was the ship unguarded at any
point?
BANNION
No, Sir. Why? Laser-field
barrier switched on automatically.
When we returned it was still
functioning.
HELENA
You're sure no one could have
got aboard?
PARKS
Impossible.
CONTINUED
44
47 CONTD.
KOENIG
You're both sure about that?
BANNION
Yes, Sir. Not without us knowing
it.
PARKS
Once took off though I did
notice something weird.
KOENIG
Yes? Go on.
PARKS
Well, Commander... for a while
I actually felt cold.. but I
May have been imagining things
...the cabin temperatures are
always a static 21 degrees.
BANNION
I noticed it too...
KOENIG
Didn't your instruments tell
you anything?
PARKS
They read normal, Sir.
HELENA
What happened then?
PARKS
I blacked out.
BANNION
I can't remember anything else,
either, Commander.
KOENIG
You men take it easy.. Doctor?
Helena walks with Koenig to the door and goes out.
47A INT. CORRIDOR. 47A
KOENIG
What do you think?
HELENA
They seen fine.
CONTINUED