Reference Library
The Episode Critics
Compiled by Martin Willey

Click on episode title for comments by Johnny Byrne (Critical commentary, 1975), Richard Houldsworth (TV Zone, 1992+), Chris Bentley (SFX, 1996), John Kenneth Muir, James O'Neill (Sci-Fi On Tape, 1997), Anthony McKay (DWB, 1992+) and others.

Number	Episode	Johnny Byrne (out of 5) (1975)	Dreamwatch (out of 10) (1996)	Chris Bentley/ SFX (1996)	Sci-Fi On Tape (out of 8) (1997)	Bob Wood (out of 10) (2002)	Bob Wood (out of 10) (2010)	Alasdair Stuart (out of 5) (2007)	Adrian Sherlock (out of 10) (2018-23)
1	Breakaway	4	7	A+	6	8.5	8	4	10
2	Matter Of Life And Death	3		B-	5	8	7	4	8
3	Black Sun	4	8	A	5	9.5	9	3	10
4	Ring Around The Moon	3	3	C-	4	7	6	2	7
5	Earthbound	3	9	A	6	9	8	3	10
6	Another Time, Another Place	3	5	A+	6	10	9.5	3	10
7	Missing Link	2	7	C+	6	8.5	8	2	8
8	Guardian of Piri	2	3	A	4	9.5	9	3	9
9	Force Of Life	5	9	A-	5	9.5	9	3	9
10	Alpha Child	3	7	B-	5	6	5	4	8
11	The Last Sunset	3	7	A+	4	9	7.5	4	9
12	Voyager's Return	3	9	B+	4	8.5	7.5	4	10
13	Collision Course	5	4	B+	5	10	9	3	10
14	Death's Other Dominion	5	10	A+	5	10	8.5	3	10
15	The Full Circle	3	5	C	3	8	6.5	2	6
16	End Of Eternity	2	5	A	4	9	8	4	9
17	War Games	5	8	A-	4	10	9.5	5	8
18	The Last Enemy	1		C	4	7	5	3	9
19	The Troubled Spirit	4		A+	5	10	9	2	9
20	Space Brain	3		B-	4	7	6.5	2	7
21	The Infernal Machine	4		A+	5	9.5	9	3	9
22	Mission Of The Darians	5		A+	5	10	9	3	9
23	Dragon's Domain	5		A+	7	10	9	4	10
24	The Testament Of Arkadia	3		A+	4	10	9	4	9
25	The Metamorph		8	A	6	9	8.5		9
26	The Exiles		3	B+	5	9	8		8
27	One Moment Of Humanity		8	B	5	10	9		7
28	All That Glisters		6	D-	1	6.5	5.5		7
29	Journey To Where		7	A-	6	10	9		10
30	The Taybor		6	D-	4	6	5		7
31	The Rules Of Luton		7	D+	5	5	4.5		7
32	The Mark Of Archanon		9	B+	4	4	3.5		6
33	Brian The Brain		6	B+		5.5	4		7
34	New Adam, New Eve		5	B		9	8		7
35	The Catacombs Of The Moon		7	B+		8.5	8		7
36	The A B Chrysalis		5	A-		9	8.5		9
37	Seed Of Destruction		4	B+		9	8		9
38	The Beta Cloud		2	C-		6	4		9
39	A Matter Of Balance			D-		6.5	6		6
40	Space Warp		4	D		6.5	5.5		8
41	The Bringers Of Wonder		6	A	4	7	7.5		10
43	The Lambda Factor		5	A-		9	8		10
44	The Seance Spectre			B-		9	8.5		8
45	Dorzak			A-		8.5	7		9
46	Devil's Planet			B+		8	7		7
47	The Immunity Syndrome		7	B		9.5	9		10
48	The Dorcons		5	B+		9	8		9

---